Sebastian Stan may have accidentally fueled one of the internet’s biggest superhero rumors. Fans are convinced the actor subtly hinted at playing Two-Face in an upcoming DC project, and social media has been in meltdown mode ever since.

The speculation exploded after fans noticed cryptic comments and suspicious details tied to recent interviews and appearances.

While nothing has officially been confirmed yet, people online are already saying Sebastian could be a perfect fit for Gotham’s iconic villain.