Andrew Garfield and Monica Barbaro fueled dating rumors after attending a performance of John Proctor Is The Villain on Broadway. The pair, seen wearing baseball caps, posed onstage with the cast at New York’s Booth Theatre on Sunday, May 4, alongside Broadway star Bonnie Milligan.

The critically acclaimed play, which recently earned seven Tony nominations including Best Play, reimagines The Crucible through the lens of high school girls in rural Georgia. As they study Arthur Miller’s classic, the students begin to challenge their views on feminism, power, and relationships.

Sadie Sink, a 2025 Tony nominee for her role as Shelby, told the story resonated with her own small-town upbringing. “It’s like, we’re working on something important,” she shared.

Garfield, 41, and Barbaro, 34, have been linked since February but haven’t commented publicly on their relationship. Their night at the theater adds fuel to the speculation.